Zachipongwe komanso zoneneza zotsutsa dziko la East Umm Kulthum ndikuipitsa mbiri yake ndipo banja lake limayankha.

Dowidar adanena kuti mawonekedwe a mayi wochedwa "adasokonezeka", monga momwe adanenera, ndipo adawonetsa kuti adachita ndi wolemba ndakatulo Rami ndi malingaliro apadera.

Iye adalongosola ubale pakati pa awiriwa ngati ubale wa nkhandwe ndi nyama yake, ndipo Dewidar adalongosola Umm Kulthum kuti ndi "wodzikonda", ndipo adanena kuti adasokoneza Rami, yemwe adachita naye monga wokonda komanso wamisala.

Madzulo aluso adayambitsa chipwirikiti ndipo adayambitsa chiwopsezo chachikulu ku Egypt Writers Union, zomwe zidapangitsa a Musicians Syndicate kulowa mumzere wamavuto, ndipo adapereka mawu kuti ayankhe pomwe adatsimikizira kuti idzayima ndi aliyense wodzikuza, woyipa komanso wochita chiwembu. kuyang'anira, ndikutsutsa zoyesayesa zonse zowononga cholowa ndi zizindikiro zaluso monga dziko la East Umm Kulthum, lomwe Anagwirizanitsa mtundu wa Aarabu mwezi uliwonse pamtima wa munthu mmodzi.

The Syndicate inadzudzula chipongwe cha olemba ndakatulo a ku Egypt, omwe adakhazikika m'mitima ya Aigupto ndi Aluya onse, kuphatikizapo wolemba ndakatulo Ahmed Ramy, Ahmed Shawky ndi Ahmed Shafiq Kamel, yemwe adakhudzidwa ndi mawu a ndakatuloyo.

Pambuyo pake, wolemba ndakatuloyo adapepesa chifukwa cha zolakwa zomwe adachita kwa Umm Kulthum ndi wolemba ndakatulo Ahmed Rami, nati, "Ndine ndani kuti ndilakwitse mkazi woimba wa Arabu, Umm Kulthum? Ndipo ndine yani kuti ndidzudzule wolemba ndakatulo amene ndinalembapo nkhani zotsimikizira chikondi ndi ulemu wanga pa luso lake ndi pulofesa kwa mibadwomibadwo?”